Captain America and Wolverine are two of Marvel’s most powerful superheroes. They display excellent leadership qualities, with Wolverine serving as a prominent fixture with the X-Men and Captain America, the Avengers.
They may also be the first characters you think of when you hear the words Avengers or X-Men. So if the Avengers nominated Captain America and the X-Men nominated Wolverine to square off in a fight, who would win?
This fight comes down to Wolverine’s adamantium skeleton vs. Captain America’s vibranium shield. Wolverine’s skeleton can withstand anything, but Cap’s shield is also made with one of the toughest metals on the planet.
Contents
Who is Wolverine?
Also called Logan or James “Jimmy” Howlett, Wolverine is one of the most well-known characters in X-Men. However, his backstory is rather contradictory and confusing, so I’ll introduce him based on what we learned in X-Men Origins: Wolverine.
Per Origins, he was born in Canada’s Northwest Territories in 1845 as James Howlett. When he saw the family groundskeeper, Thomas Logan, killing his father, this prompted Howlett’s bone claw mutation to emerge, which he used to kill Thomas.
The incident caused Howlett to run away with his half-brother, Victor Creed (Sabretooth), and the duo ended up fighting in nearly every war imaginable. They saw action in the American Civil War (1861-1865), World War I (1914-1918), World War II (1939-1945), and in 1973, the Vietnam War.
Following an incident that got Howlett and Creed subjected to an execution that the duo survived, they were given a role in Team X by Major William Stryker.
This team’s membership also included an array of mutants like Chris Bradley, Fred Dukes (Blob), John Wraith (Kestrel), Wade Wilson (Deadpool), and David North (Agent Zero). It was around this time that Howlett started going by Logan.
His time with Team X didn’t last, and he eventually returned to Canada to work as a logger. However, when Stryker and North warned Logan that Victor killed Wilson and Bradley, he sought out his half-brother.
Logan received his indestructible adamantium skeleton thanks to Stryker. Stryker also wanted to erase Logan’s memory, but Logan overheard this and escaped, only for North to pursue him.
Logan fought and killed North before locating Wraith and Dukes, who told him about Three Mile Island. He found his way to the island, killed Wilson, who was revealed as Stryker’s “mutant killer,” and engaged in a showdown with Stryker.
This showdown resulted in Logan’s memory loss, but when he came to, he saw a dog tag labeled Wolverine, and it’s the alter-ego he’s gone by ever since.
Who Is Captain America?
Steve Rogers (Captain America) was the first Avenger in MCU’s timeline. His roots trace back to World War II, where a weak, unhealthy Rogers sought to join the US military and was only given a chance when Dr. Abraham Erskine cleared him for enlistment.
Rogers stated that it was important for him to represent the United States in the war, which piqued Erskine’s interest. This dedication also led Erskine to recommend Rogers as the subject of the Strategic Scientific Reserve’s Super-Soldier Experiment.
As the experiment’s subject, Rogers transformed from his physically weak self to a tall, muscular, athletic specimen capable of superhuman speed, strength, and endurance.
Later, Rogers became known as Captain America, and he took part in many death-defying missions. The first involved rescuing his best friend, Bucky Barnes, and a company of prisoners from a Hydra facility, before defeating Johann Schmidt (Red Skull).
Rogers later fought in the Battle of New York (The Avengers), before helping the Avengers defeat Ultron. He then resisted the Sokovia Accords, leading a faction of Avengers against Tony Stark (Iron Man) and those seeking to adopt the Accords.
Rogers and his faction lost, forcing them to become fugitives. He reunited with Stark and the Avengers during the Infinity War.
Despite initially coming off on the losing end in that war, Rogers also helped lead the Avengers through time to collect the Infinity Stones and ultimately defeat Thanos.
Following the Infinity War, Rogers returned the Stones. He then returned to the 1940s, marrying and sharing a life with Peggy Carter. In Endgame’s closing scenes, he passed his trademark vibranium shield to Sam Wilson.
Wolverine’s Abilities
Wolverine’s adamantium skeleton is perhaps his greatest strength, though some may argue it’s his signature retractable claws.
But his abilities don’t stop there, as he boasts superhuman strength, enhanced night vision, sense of smell, and hearing. His self-healing breaks the laws of physics, and he can even keep himself from drowning since his lungs can simply regenerate if underwater for extended periods.
He also possesses an incredible amount of wisdom thanks to his long lifespan. Wolverine has been around since the 19th century, and he has experience fighting in multiple wars.
This has allowed him to master numerous hand-to-hand combat styles and weapons, and his enhanced memory lets him recall what he’s learned at will.
While the world evolved technologically, Wolverine evolved with it. This has given him a strong background in science and mechanics. If facing any opponent whose suit is scientifically enhanced, Wolverine would have little trouble subduing them.
Captain America’s Abilities
After being injected with the super-soldier serum, Rogers acquired an array of abilities. His most notable abilities included immunity to fatigue, expertise in hand-to-hand combat and martial arts, superior healing, slow biological aging, and increased metabolism, eyesight, and intelligence.
Rogers is also worthy of wielding Thor’s Mjolnir, allowing him to access the hammer’s magical properties. If an opponent has Cap in a precarious situation, he can catch them off-guard with Mjolnir and perhaps quickly end a fight.
You may know Rogers best for his trademark vibranium shield, which he acquired in The First Avenger. His bullet-proof shield is so strong, it can even block weapons as powerful as Thor’s Mjolnir.
The shield can also protect Rogers from serious injury if he falls. And while we know Rogers can resist such trauma better than the normal human, he still has his limits. If Rogers falls from an extreme height, his shield will act as a shock absorber.
Offensively, the shield can knock down several opponents. He can either throw it directly at a villain, or at another object. The latter move allows it to ricochet at an angle, catching opponents off-guard.
With the shield’s recall feature, Rogers isn’t without his shield for long. It always makes its way back to him.
In Captain America: Civil War, we saw Rogers use the shield to cut himself free of Spider-Man’s (Peter Parker’s) webs.
Wolverine’s Weaknesses
Water is one of Wolverine’s few weaknesses. While I outlined that his enhanced healing keeps him from drowning, Wolverine’s adamantium skeleton makes it tough for him to stay afloat. The skeleton also makes Wolverine vulnerable to anything magnetic.
It’s true that Wolverine has a great memory, but he also suppresses traumatic memories. This may seem like a strength, but if the memory involved losing a battle or making a dramatic mistake, Wolverine could end up making the same mistake, and that could cost him in a fight.
He can also rely too much on his claws, which is ironic considering his immense knowledge of martial arts and combat styles.
Wolverine can also take unnecessary chances in a fight, which has led to several losses. In Spider-Man vs. Wolverine #1, Wolverine seemed to underestimate Spider-Man. The same thing occurred in X-Men: Schism #5 and #6 when Wolverine lost to Cyclops.
Captain America’s Weaknesses
While Cap’s vibranium shield will evoke damage, it isn’t the perfect weapon. It lacks adequate range when compared to other Avengers’ weapons of choice. For example, Iron Man’s repulsor blasts can shoot much further. Ditto for Thor’s lightning strikes.
Against any opponent, Cap must find a way to get himself close enough for an accurate throw. He must also take note of an opponent’s weapon and use his shield to deflect its strikes.
Technology is another huge weakness. Having been born in 1918, crash-landing in 1945, and being frozen in the Arctic for nearly 70 years, Rogers finds tech confusing.
While he can get around this for simple contraptions like flash drives, we also saw this weakness on full display in The Avengers.
When Tony Stark needed Cap to tell him which relays ran in an overload position on an engine control panel, Cap replied that, “it seems to run on some form of electricity.”
Wolverine vs. Captain America: Side-By-Side Comparison
| Character | Wolverine | Captain America |
| Real Name | James Howlett/Logan | Steve Rogers |
| Weapon of Choice | Retractable Claws | Vibranium Shield |
| Biggest Strength | Adamantium Skeleton | Enhanced Physicality |
| Biggest Weakness | One-Dimensional Fighter | Technology |
Wolverine vs. Captain America
In Avengers vs. X-Men #3, Wolverine squared off against Captain America. Cap won that fight, but you can put an asterisk by that since Hank Pym interfered. Otherwise, Wolverine would have won.
One huge advantage Wolverine has over Captain America is that his adamantium skeleton can withstand anything, including Cap’s vibranium shield. We have seen the shield do some remarkable things, but it would be tough for the shield to damage the skeleton.
Thanks to Wolverine’s skeleton being so tough to damage, it would give him all the advantages he needs to get the upper hand against Captain America. Once he withstands the shield’s impact, Wolverine can attack.
With his super strength and his claws’ ability to cut through anything, Wolverine easily gets the upper hand over Cap. This isn’t saying Cap wouldn’t put up a good fight. He would, but overall, Wolverine can circumvent Cap’s greatest weapon, the vibranium shield.
Sion Fawkes has been covering Star Wars since January 2022, expanding his expertise in Star Wars Canon, Legends, and MCU. When not writing, you can find Sion in the gym or running trails. He also likes watching sports and listening to audiobooks.