Earth 616 vs Earth 838: Which Superheroes Are Stronger?

Comparing superheroes from different universes is always a fun and fascinating topic.

In this article, I’ll take a look at some key matchups between heroes from Earth 616 and Earth 838.

Let’s find out which versions of our favorite superheroes are stronger and why!

Captain America vs. Captain Carter

Captain America (Earth 616)

Captain America from Earth 616, also known as Steve Rogers, is renowned for his incredible stamina, fighting & leading skills, and strategic mind.

His iconic shield is not just a symbol but a highly effective weapon and defensive tool. Cap uses his shield to deflect attacks, immobilize enemies, and even engage powerful entities like Thor and Thanos.

His shield boosts his power to incredible levels, allowing him to stand toe-to-toe with some of the mightiest beings in the Marvel universe.

He’s also the only mortal that’s worthy of the Mjolnir, which lets him use the power of thunder.

Steve is famous for his line, “I can do this all day,” and he has proven this resilience and determination countless times.

Whether it’s battling through hordes of enemies or holding his ground against seemingly insurmountable odds, Captain America embodies perseverance.

He literally fights until his enemies are defeated or give up themselves, showcasing his endurance and unwavering spirit.

Captain Carter (Earth 838)

Captain Carter, the variant from Earth 838, brings her own set of skills and bravery to the table. She wields a similar shield and exhibits remarkable combat abilities.

However, her moment in “Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness” highlights a stark contrast. After declaring, “I can do this all day,” she is immediately killed under her own iconic shield manipulated by Wanda.

This tragic end suggests that while Captain Carter possesses strength and courage, she may not have the same level of battlefield experience or tactical ingenuity as Steve Rogers.

The brutal efficiency with which Wanda dispatches her implies that Captain Carter, despite her abilities, falls short when compared to the relentless and seasoned Captain America from Earth 616.

Winner: Captain America (Earth 616)

Captain Marvel Earth 616 vs. Captain Marvel Earth 838

Captain Marvel (Earth 616)

Captain Marvel, also known as Carol Danvers, from Earth 616, is one of the most powerful heroes in the Marvel universe.

Her powers include super strength, flight, and energy projection, making her a force to be reckoned with.

In “Avengers: Endgame,” we see just how powerful she is when she single-handedly pierces Thanos’ massive warship, the Sanctuary II, with ease.

This incredible display of power highlights her invulnerability and sheer might. Carol’s ability to absorb and manipulate energy further amplifies her strength, allowing her to take on and overpower some of the most formidable foes in the MCU.

In a moment, she even got the power to fight against Thanos with all the Infinity Stones.

Captain Marvel (Earth 838)

Captain Marvel from Earth 838, aka Maria Rambeau, while also incredibly powerful, met an unfortunate end with just a statue falling on her.

This suggests that she might not be as resilient as her Earth 616 counterpart, who has survived numerous battles and catastrophic events.

The comparison underscores the superior endurance and combat prowess of Carol Danvers from Earth 616, making her the stronger of the two.

Winner: Captain Marvel (Earth 616)

Wanda Earth 616 vs. Wanda Earth 838

Wanda (Earth 616)

Wanda Maximoff, or the Scarlet Witch from Earth 616, is arguably one of the most powerful beings in the multiverse.

Her powers were significantly amplified after reading the Darkhold, making her an almost unstoppable force. The Darkhold grants Wanda the ability to control and manipulate reality, as well as perform dark magic rituals such as dreamwalking.

Dreamwalking allows Wanda from Earth 616 to possess her counterpart’s body in another universe.

In “Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness,” we see Wanda 616 using this ability to take over the body of Wanda 838.

While in control, she demonstrates her overwhelming power by defeating the most powerful members of the Illuminati on Earth 838, including Mister Fantastic, Black Bolt, and Professor X.

Wanda (Earth 838)

While Wanda from Earth 838 is powerful, she hasn’t reached the same level of might as her Earth 616 version.

She lacks the Darkhold’s dark magic enhancements, which make Earth 616 Wanda far more formidable and dangerous.

The events in the multiverse show that Wanda 838, without these enhancements, could not stand against the might of Wanda 616’s powers.

Winner: Wanda (Earth 616)

Doctor Strange Earth 616 vs. Doctor Strange Earth 838

Doctor Strange (Earth 616)

Doctor Strange from Earth 616 is the Sorcerer Supreme, master of the mystic arts, and protector of the realm from magical threats.

In “Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness,” we see his struggle against Wanda Maximoff, who destroys the Book of Vishanti before he can use it.

This leaves Strange relying solely on the dark magic from the Darkhold to confront her, limiting his potential power.

Doctor Strange (Earth 838)

On the other hand, Doctor Strange from Earth 838 managed to achieve something monumental. As revealed in a flashback from “Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness,” he took on Thanos by himself, without the full support of the Avengers.

This Doctor Strange utilized both the Darkhold and the Book of Vishanti to defeat the Mad Titan, showcasing his mastery of both dark and light magic.

This suggests that Doctor Strange 838’s access to such a potent source of beneficial magic made him more powerful than his Earth 616 counterpart.

Winner: Doctor Strange (Earth 838)